Farmington’s Solar Saga: Neighbors Clash Over 62-Foot ‘Space Laser’ in Front Yard

Balancing Green Energy and Neighborhood Charm: Farmington’s Zoning Board Finds a Middle Ground

By Jack Beckett
The Farmington Mercury

Farmington took a decisive step into the future of sustainable energy on September 16, 2024, when the Zoning Board of Appeals approved a controversial solar panel installation at 115 Town Farm Road. The meeting reflected an ongoing challenge for communities like Farmington: embracing green energy while preserving the character of suburban neighborhoods.

At the center of the debate was James Yao, trustee of the JWY Ohana Living Trust, who sought a variance to install 35 solar panels in his front yard. What seemed like a personal effort to become more energy-independent quickly became a community-wide discussion about aesthetics, property values, and the changing face of Farmington.

The Proposal: Powering a Green Future, But at What Cost?

James Yao’s proposal wasn’t just about saving on his electric bills. It was a bid to reduce his home’s dependence on the grid entirely by installing solar panels to power a new geothermal heating system and hybrid water heater. But there was one problem: his backyard—where such installations are usually placed—was unsuitable. Tall trees blocked the sun, and his septic system and geothermal wells complicated the layout.

“I’ve done everything I can to find a spot in the back, but it’s just not viable,” Yao explained during the hearing. “The rear yard would generate about 7 kilowatt hours—well short of the 27 kilowatt hours I need. The front yard is the only option.”

Yao’s project was designed to take him off oil and tap into renewable energy, a move in line with both state and national efforts to combat climate change. But the specifics—35 solar panels stretching 62 feet across, standing 11 feet high—had some neighbors worried.

Neighborhood Concerns: Aesthetic Impact and Property Values

David Kovich, Yao’s neighbor to the north at 117 Town Farm Road, wasn’t opposed to green energy in theory. In practice, though, he wasn’t thrilled about a massive solar array next door. “This isn’t about stopping solar energy,” Kovich said. “It’s about the size and visibility of this thing. It’s going to be an eyesore.”

Kovich argued that the array would significantly lower property values in the area. “I’ve lived here my whole life, and we’ve maintained our homes well. Now, imagine trying to sell a house with a 65-foot solar array staring you in the face.”

Kovich suggested Yao had other options, like hiring an electrician to replace his outdated electrical line or using propane to power his home. “Why not explore less invasive alternatives first?” he asked.

Compromise on the Table: Finding Middle Ground

After listening to both sides, the Zoning Board of Appeals focused on finding a compromise that would satisfy both Yao’s environmental goals and Kovich’s concerns about property values and aesthetics. The idea of a berm, or raised earth barrier, paired with a line of mature arborvitae trees was proposed to screen the array from neighboring properties.

Yao was open to the idea. “I don’t want to create an eyesore for my neighbors, either. I’m more than willing to add trees or a berm to block the view,” he said.

Commissioners, including Marian McPherson-Burrow, saw the project’s benefits but shared Kovich’s concerns. “We support renewable energy, but this is a significant structure,” she said. “We need to ensure it’s done in a way that respects the surrounding homes.”

The board ultimately voted to approve the installation of 35 panels but included several key conditions. First, Yao must work with town staff to install a berm and plant mature evergreens to obscure the view from Kovich’s property. Second, the approval covers only 35 panels—Yao must return to the board to seek approval for additional panels after demonstrating the increased energy needs of his geothermal system.

The Larger Picture: A Model for Future Decisions

This zoning decision is about more than just one home. It reflects the challenges that will likely arise as more Farmington residents look to embrace renewable energy. The town now has a precedent for how to navigate the tension between progressive energy solutions and maintaining the aesthetic character of its neighborhoods.

“We’re at a crossroads where Farmington needs to decide how we want to evolve,” said Chairman John Schumacher. “We want to encourage sustainability, but we also want to preserve the charm that makes this community what it is.”

For Yao, the approval brings him closer to energy independence, while for neighbors like Kovich, the added berm and trees may soften the visual impact. As Farmington moves forward, this case will likely serve as a template for future zoning discussions as the town continues to balance its green ambitions with its suburban roots.

Watch the Full Meeting

If you missed the action, you can catch the full Zoning Board of Appeals meeting here.

Shout-Out to Our Sponsor!

Of course, while solar energy may be contentious, there’s nothing controversial about our sponsor, Farmington Storage. Whether you need a place to stash your summer gear or hide from your zoning drama (kidding, zoning’s important!), they’ve got you covered. Farmington Storage is conveniently located at 155 Scott Swamp Road. Call them at 860.777.4001. Because the only thing they don’t store is grudges. 😉

Reporting live (okay, maybe from my desk, but still…) where the zoning drama is just as exciting as it sounds.

Until next time,
Jack Beckett
Professional Snooper of Solar Panels, Town Meetings, and Unsolved Mysteries (a.k.a. Why is my coffee always cold?)

Looking for more insightful stories and Farmington happenings? You’ve come to the right place! Check out our other sections:

• Editorials: Thought-provoking takes on the issues that matter. Click here
• Farmington Real Estate Listings: Curious about what’s for sale? Click here
• Election 2024 Coverage: Stay in the know for the upcoming elections. Click here
• Law Enforcement News: Keeping the community informed. Click here
• Farmington Historic District Updates: Preserving our past for the future. Click here
• Wetlands Committee Reports: The most exciting thing about water that isn’t a beach day! Click here
• Farmington High School News: Stay in the loop with the latest from FHS. Click here
• Zoning News: For the policy wonks out there. Click here
• Board of Education Reports: What’s happening in our schools? Click here
• Job Listings: Positions available in Farmington. Click here

Want More?

Subscribe to The Farmington Mercury’s newsletter for exclusive updates, in-depth interviews, and breaking local news.

Got a question? Need to reach us? Contact us here – we don’t bite (unless there’s pizza involved).

Stay informed. Stay engaged. Stay connected with The Farmington Mercury.