A Long Night at Town Hall Ends With Big Votes—and Bigger Stakes
On Monday, January 26, 2026, the Farmington Town Plan and Zoning Commission worked through a meeting that moved from signage at a former bookstore, to two residential accessory-structure approvals, to a continued dispute over aquifer process at Brickyard Road—before landing on the night’s central vote: approval of a new zoning framework and site plan for 62 apartments at 20 Scott Swamp Road. 🗳️
Sponsor Plug (60 words):
Coverage of this meeting is brought to you by Farmington Storage, because even zoning packets need somewhere dry. Located at 155 Scott Swamp Road in Farmington, CT, and reachable at 860-777-4001, they’ll hold your boxes while Town Hall debates setbacks. Click Farmington Storage to rent space, then come back—we’ll still be last to breaking news with facility overhead already handled. 📦☕
By The Numbers
- 1599 Southeast Road: monument sign approved; former Barnes & Noble site now moving to multi-tenant use
- ADRC: Tim Eagles reappointed for a three-year term
- Miss Porter’s School: temporary athletic field lighting application accepted; hearing set for Feb. 23, 2026
- 14 Mountain Road: 22’ x 30’ detached garage approved; 660 sq. ft. with 355 sq. ft. loft
- Farmington Motorsports (148 Brickyard Road): public hearing opened then continued to Feb. 9, 2026; one abstention
- 35 Mountain Spring Road: 24’ x 30’ barn approved; 720 sq. ft. plus lean-to
- 20 Scott Swamp Road: 62 units approved via SSROZ text amendment, zone change, and site plan approval
Roll Call, Weather, and the Set-Up
Town Planner Shannon Rutherford opened the meeting with roll call. Present were Commissioners Bob Canto, Phil Cordero, Josh Davidson, David St. Germain, and Peter Zarella, with Chair Liz Sanford presiding. Alternates present included Lisa Fagan, Rob Ingrid, and Taylor Poxon (noted on the record as “Taylor”). The meeting was held in hybrid form at Town Hall Council Chambers, with online participation through the town website.
Legal notices were read into the record for three applications scheduled for public hearing:
- Farmington Motorsports at 148 Brickyard Road
- James W. Panito at 35 Mountain Spring Road
- Metro Realty Management Corporation at 20 Scott Swamp Road (including regulation amendment, zone change, and site plan approval under Connecticut General Statutes Section 8-30g)
1599 Southeast Road: Signage for a Building in Transition
The commission approved a sign application associated with redevelopment of the former Barnes & Noble building at 1599 Southeast Road, described as transitioning into a multi-tenant space. Steve Barzlek, owner of Goldfish Swim School and a partner in the building, presented remotely. He said Hanoosh Jewelers would occupy the front half, Goldfish Swim School the rear half, and the middle section was expected to be one to three additional tenants.
The site was described as split between Farmington and Newington, roughly 60% and 40%, respectively. The approved request moved the monument sign closer to the road (still outside the right-of-way), increased height by three feet ten inches as permitted in the regulation, and used ground lighting. Commissioners asked about the sign orientation and lighting method; the vote was unanimous.
Advisory Committee: Tim Eagles Reappointed
Rutherford explained the Architectural Design Review Committee (ADRC) is advisory to the commission for Unionville Center and Farmington Center zones, with nine positions and eight seated members at the time. Tim Eagles, identified as an architect, was reappointed for another three-year term by unanimous vote.
Miss Porter’s: Temporary Lights, Hearing Set
The commission accepted an application from Miss Porter’s School for temporary lighting for limited nighttime use of athletic fields, described as one week in the summer until 10 p.m. The locations were read into the motion as 8478 Maple Street, 8288 Garden Street, and 11 Maple Street, in R20 and R12 zones. The public hearing was scheduled for Monday, February 23, 2026.
14 Mountain Road: A Garage Slightly Over the Line
Chair Sanford disclosed on the record that the applicant, William Clark, lives two doors down from her and is her neighbor, stating there was no financial interest involved.
Clark sought special permit and site plan approval for a 22-by-30-foot, 660-square-foot two-car detached garage with a 355-square-foot loft. He cited Article 4, Section 30, “Expanded Home,” explaining the accessory structure exceeded 30% of the principal residence size. He said assessor records listed the home at 2,122 square feet, producing a maximum accessory structure threshold of 636 square feet; the proposal exceeded that by 24 square feet.
Clark said an existing 400-square-foot garage built in 1940 would remain and be used for storage. He stated the property is in the Farmington Historic District, and the Historic District Commission granted a Certificate of Appropriateness with conditions on materials.
Commissioners asked about utility service and use; Clark said the space would not be occupied, and the only utility planned was electric. Rutherford noted drainage would be addressed based on soil conditions, to avoid nuisance to adjoining property. No public comment was offered in-room or online. The commission approved the application by unanimous vote.
Farmington Motorsports: Continued, With a Process Dispute on the Record
The Farmington Motorsports public hearing was opened and continued to February 9, 2026 because the applicant and attorney were not available.
During the continuance discussion, Commissioner Davidson raised concerns about procedure and argued that aquifer-related review should occur before site plan review, noting the commission also serves as the Aquifer Protection Agency and referencing the concept of a “facility” under common control across contiguous parcels. Rutherford stated the Town Attorney advised opening and continuing without discussion in the applicant’s absence, while also noting the applicant’s attorney and town counsel had been alerted and that she had contacted DEEP and forwarded documentation, including information from 2018 related to the use.
A vote to continue to February 9 passed, with one abstention recorded.
35 Mountain Spring Road: Panito’s Barn Approved
James Panito, of 35 Mountain Spring Road, presented an application for a barn in excess of 700 square feet. He described a post-and-beam structure from Hinman Lumber, 24 by 30 feet (720 square feet), with a lean-to along the side (10 feet by length, described as 240 square feet). He said the barn would have electricity but no plumbing and would be used as a woodworking workshop. He also mentioned he was considering a heat pump but had not finalized that plan.
Commissioners asked about access, grading, gutters, nearby wetlands, tree removal, and cleanup. Panito said he planned gravel for access and had not planned to install gutters. A commissioner asked about invasive cleanup impacts near wetlands; Panito said he planned to clean up and use logs from his property. No public comment was offered. The commission approved the application unanimously.
20 Scott Swamp Road: A New Zone, A New Site Plan, A Demolition
The night’s final public hearing focused on Metro’s redevelopment of the former Touchpoints skilled nursing facility property, described as approximately 5.48 acres in a Business Residential zone. Attorney Christian Hoeb described the site context—near Scott Swamp Road, Route 6, Main Street/Route 10—with commercial uses nearby including a Dunkin’ Donuts and Exxon station, and a CVS pharmacy.
Hoeb said Touchpoints closed in August 2023. He described its prior operation as 24/7 with 120 beds historically and 105 residents at closure, with over 100 staff members, and said it became functionally obsolete and closed amid Connecticut Medicaid underfunding.
The Application Structure
Attorney Andrea Gomes described the application as three parts:
- Text amendment creating the Scott Swamp Road Opportunity Zone (SSROZ)
- Zone change of the parcel from BR to SSROZ
- Site plan approval for a 62-unit multifamily community, pursued under Connecticut General Statutes Section 8-30g
She stated abutter mailing occurred January 12 and the hearing sign was posted January 15, with newspaper notice published twice and filings made with the Town Clerk in advance.
Units, Affordability, and Supportive Housing
Gomes and Metro representatives Kyle Richards and Ben Tripp described the proposal as five buildings with 62 apartments: 26 one-bedroom, 34 two-bedroom, and two three-bedroom units. They described the project as financed through the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit program and stated affordability would be governed by program rules, with a 50-year restriction referenced in the hearing.
A key component described was 14 supportive housing units for clients of The Arc of the Farmington Valley (Favar), with on-site staff support. Trisha Nato, Director of Supportive Housing for The Arc of the Farmington Valley, said staffing would be on-site 24/7, with shift staffing levels varying by time and day, and that there would typically be vans on a site of this size.
Parking and Traffic
The plan included 90 parking spaces. Counsel and engineers discussed how the SSROZ parking standard could be reduced based on evidence of need, including the supportive housing component. Staff and the applicant walked through the parking math during commissioner questions, emphasizing that the plan exceeded the reduced requirement.
Traffic engineer Mark Vertucci described a traffic impact study using ITE trip-generation methodology, with counts conducted October 9, 2025 and projected to a 2028 design year using a DOT growth factor. He described the projected site traffic as 35 trips in the morning peak hour and 37 in the afternoon peak hour, and he stated that the net increase compared to the prior nursing facility use was modest. He also described potential signal timing adjustments and a possible restriping concept on Scott Swamp Road to improve operations near the driveway, noting work would be reviewed through a DOT encroachment permit process.
Civil, Stormwater, Wetlands, and Conservation Area
Engineer Tom Daly described the site as having limited elevation change across the parcel and said the plan kept development within the existing disturbed footprint, with stormwater quality features added where the prior site had none. He referenced hydrodynamic separation and infiltration approaches consistent with updated DEP stormwater guidance, and he described wetlands-related revisions, including pulling back from wetlands using a retaining wall and committing the rear green area to a permanent conservation restriction with markers.
The commission noted the wetlands permit had been received January 7.
Public Comment and Written Support
One online public commenter, Phil Chabot of 718 Camp Street, expressed support, identifying his work experience reviewing low-income developments and noting he serves on an EDZ commission in town.
Rutherford displayed and entered multiple letters of support into the record, including letters from Favar families and local businesses.
Vote: Three Motions, Three Effective Dates
After closing the public hearing, the commission voted to approve:
- SSROZ text amendment (effective 16 days after legal notice publication)
- Zone change BR → SSROZ (effective 17 days after legal notice publication)
- Site plan approval (effective 18 days after legal notice publication), with conditions referenced in the staff agenda review and acknowledged as acceptable by the applicant
The votes were unanimous.
Planners Report: Tungsten Mead Park Grant Projects
Rutherford delivered a planners report item concerning Tungsten Mead Park improvements tied to a state grant application prepared by Jesse Catano, Farmington’s Director of Recreation (online during the meeting). Rutherford described the grant as funding bundled upgrades that would otherwise require multi-year capital scheduling.
Projects described included:
- Replacement of athletic field lighting at baseball and softball fields by converting existing fixtures to LED heads (no new stanchions)
- Renovation of baseball dugouts and press box
- Full renovation of basketball courts to a post-tension concrete surface
- ADA access and sidewalk work associated with the Setlow Family Turf Field, including a concrete bleacher pad and possible expanded sidewalk depending on bid pricing
- Replacement of safety netting poles and fencing at baseball and softball fields; softball fence moved approximately 70 feet toward home plate to align with Title IX requirements, shifting that field to girls softball use, with men’s league use moving to the north field
- Relocation of the kickboard due to fencing changes
- Sound system upgrades at Grocki Field, the softball field, and the Al Bell field, described as limited to certain uses (high school and American Legion use referenced)
Commissioner Poxon raised Japanese knotweed concerns at Tungsten Mead Park; Catano said invasive management was not included in the scope of this grant, which was based on a 2020 Tungsten Mead improvement plan, but said future evaluation and maintenance planning could address it.
Minutes and Scheduling
The commission approved minutes from:
- December 8, 2025 (one abstention recorded during the vote)
- January 12, 2026 administrative and regular meetings (one commissioner noted on the record they watched the full recording)
Rutherford flagged the April 13 meeting as potentially impacted by Farmington spring break week and reported that the Chair and Secretary expected to be out; Commissioner Zarella also said he would be out of town. Rutherford asked commissioners to check schedules and said applications could be adjusted to avoid hearings if quorum risk developed.
The meeting was adjourned by Chair Sanford.
What To Watch Next
Two dates now sit on the town’s near-term calendar:
- Feb. 9, 2026: the continued Farmington Motorsports public hearing, where aquifer process questions are likely to return
- Feb. 23, 2026: the Miss Porter’s temporary lighting hearing
And at 20 Scott Swamp Road, the vote moves the project from hearing room to the next layer of approvals: DOT work in the right-of-way, demolition planning, and the long grind between paper approvals and ground work. ✅
About the Author
Jack Beckett covers Farmington with a notebook, a deadline, and a coffee that’s doing most of the heavy lifting. ☕ If you like civic process (or simply enjoy watching it unfold in public), start with the newsroom explainer at About The Farmington Mercury, then dive into Editorial and Zoning. If your interests run to listings, arrests, boards, or jobs, we’ve built doors for that too: For Sale, Law Enforcement, Farmington CT Historic District Commission, Farmington Wetlands Committee, Farmington CT High School, Farmington CT Board Of Education, and Positions Available. And yes: message us on X, Twitter, or as we call it Twix/ at WeFarmington On X. 🐦
If you want the fine print (we do): here’s the official map of the operation—who we are, how to reach us, and the policies that keep the lights on and the trackers off.
- Learn the project: About The Farmington Mercury
- Send tips, corrections, or meeting agendas: Contact Us
- What we collect and why: Privacy
- The rules of the road: Terms Of Service
- For media requests: Media
Creative Commons License
© 2026 The Farmington Mercury / Mercury Local
This article, “A Long Night at Town Hall Ends With Big Votes—and Bigger Stakes,” by Jack Beckett is licensed under CC BY-ND 4.0.
“A Long Night at Town Hall Ends With Big Votes—and Bigger Stakes”
by Jack Beckett, The Farmington Mercury (CC BY-ND 4.0)
