Preservation Meets Modernization
On May 21, 2024, the Farmington Historic District Commission convened to review several applications aimed at enhancing the functionality and comfort of properties while preserving the historical charm of Main Street. The meeting saw robust discussions and thoughtful deliberations, resulting in the approval of crucial home improvements and the postponement of one significant application.
Heat Pump Installation at 15 Main Street
Applicant’s Presentation
Matthew Kleber, co-owner of 15 Main Street, presented the first application of the evening, seeking approval for the installation of two heat pumps with ducting. He explained the current lack of air conditioning in the house, noting the inefficiency and problems with window units, especially during heavy rains.
“Currently, we don’t have any air conditioning. We do have some radiated heat, but we have no AC,” Kleber stated. “Last year, we had five window units in the house, which was a big pain to install and remove, and we got water in the house because we couldn’t remove the units.”
Commission’s Evaluation and Approval
The commission carefully reviewed the application, focusing on the placement and visibility of the units from the street. Kleber assured them that the units would be discreetly positioned and obscured by shrubs.
Commission member Michelle Phelan appreciated the addition of shrubs to hide the units, saying, “Thanks for adding the shrubs to obscure the units.”
After a brief discussion and no objections from the public, the commission unanimously approved the application.
“All in favor signify by saying aye,” said Jay Bambara, the chair. “Aye,” responded all members.
Window Replacement at 15 Main Street
Challenges with Existing Windows
Following the heat pump discussion, Matthew Kleber presented a second application for 15 Main Street, seeking to replace the old, single-pane wood windows with new Harvey windows. He highlighted the issues with the current windows, including water seepage and damage.
“We’d like to replace old wood windows with new double-pane Harvey windows. The current windows are single-pane, damaged, and we’re getting some water seepage,” Kleber explained.
Commission’s Approval and Conditions
The commission discussed the proposal, confirming that the new windows would maintain the historical grid pattern. Joanne Lawson noted the consistency with previous approvals, stating, “Thank you for pointing out that these are the same windows recently approved for 24 Main. If we liked them then, we should like them now.”
With no objections from the public, the commission approved the window replacement application.
“I’ll make a motion that we grant a temporary certificate of appropriateness to replace windows and remove storm windows at 15 Main Street as presented,” Joanne Lawson moved. The motion passed unanimously.
Composite Material Windows for 96 Main Street
Presentation by Renewal by Anderson
David McClellan, representing Renewal by Anderson of Southern New England, presented an application to replace windows at 96 Main Street with a new composite material. He emphasized the historical accuracy and durability of their Fiber-X windows, which have been approved in other historic districts like Sharon and the historic mile in Providence.
“We are looking for a certificate of appropriateness to replace the existing windows with our composite material windows, which have been used in historical applications in Sharon, Lakeville, and the historic mile in Providence, Rhode Island,” McClellan explained.
Concerns and Deliberations
The commission expressed interest in the new material but had reservations about approving it without seeing a local example. James Calciano requested to view similar installations nearby to ensure compatibility with the historic district’s aesthetics.
McClellan responded, “I will find these addresses for you. We do have a list of customers who have already done so.”
Decision to Table the Motion
Given the need for further inspection, the commission decided to table the motion until the next meeting.
“Let’s table the motion until next month,” said Jay Bambara. “We’ll take this up again in June.”
New Fence for First Church of Christ Playground
Proposal Details
Biff Schuckinger presented the final application of the evening, proposing a new steel fence for the playground at the First Church of Christ. He explained that the current fence required constant maintenance and that the new fence would be more durable and aesthetically pleasing.
“We’re looking to replace the world’s most maintenance-demanding fence around the playground with a new steel fence. We decided on the Montage Plus system, which is cheaper and more durable,” Schuckinger explained.
Commission’s Discussion and Approval
The commission discussed the materials and design changes, ultimately agreeing that the new fence would enhance the playground’s safety and appearance.
“I think the black fence will look good and tie the area together,” said Michelle Phelan.
With no objections, the commission approved the application unanimously.
“I’ll make a motion to accept the First Church of Christ 1652 application for temporary certificate of appropriateness to replace the fence around the playground at 75 Main Street,” moved Joanne Lawson. The motion was seconded and approved.
Conclusion: Balancing Historical Preservation and Modern Needs
The Farmington Historic District Commission’s meeting demonstrated a careful balance between preserving the town’s historical character and accommodating necessary modern upgrades. The approvals for heat pumps, window replacements, and a new fence reflect a commitment to maintaining Farmington’s heritage while embracing contemporary conveniences. The commission’s decision to table the composite window application shows their dedication to thorough review and consideration. As Farmington evolves, these thoughtful deliberations will ensure that its historical charm is preserved for future generations.
This post is brought to you by Farmington Storage in Farmington, CT. Located at 155 Scott Swamp Road, Farmington Storage supports local journalism and is proud to contribute to our community. For storage needs, contact them at 860.777.4001. Thank you, Farmington Storage, for your support!
Farmington Storage: We Support Local Journalism, We Are Farmington.
