Creating a Feedback-First Culture: Why It’s Essential for Local Business Growth & How to Avoid the Pitfalls of Ruinous Empathy
Let’s get real, Farmington. Your business can only thrive if you stop holding back and give your team the feedback they deserve. Here’s the deal: being “nice” isn’t helping anyone. It’s not driving growth, it’s not keeping customers happy, and it’s certainly not making your team stronger. It would help if you had a feedback-first culture where honesty reigns, and yes, that means having tough conversations.
Before we jump into the how, a special shout-out to Farmington Storage for holding our emotional baggage—and probably yours, too. When you’ve got the feedback you’ve been storing up, call them. They’ve got space at 155 Scott Swamp Road, or ring them at 860.777.4001. Now, let’s dive in.
Why a Feedback-First Culture is Critical for Small Businesses
1. Feedback Drives Growth, Not Niceness
Feedback isn’t just corporate fluff; it’s how businesses grow. You don’t get better by avoiding the tough stuff. If your employees are consistently underperforming, but you’re too “nice” to tell them, your business isn’t scaling—it’s sinking.
As Kim Scott says in Radical Candor, “The most important thing I think you can do for somebody who’s really good and who’s really being counted on is to point out to them when their work isn’t good enough. And to do it very clearly and to articulate why.” So, stop avoiding it. Direct feedback means direct improvement.
2. It Strengthens Team Trust
Here’s the deal—without feedback, your team isn’t functioning at full power. They’re not mind readers. If they don’t know what’s working and what’s failing, expect confusion and crossed wires. You need to build a culture where feedback isn’t feared—it’s encouraged.
Scott nails it: “When people trust you and believe you care about them, they are much more likely to… tell you what they really think about what you are doing well and, more importantly, not doing so well.”
3. Feedback Saves You from Losing Your Best People
Want to retain your top talent? Then give them regular feedback—both positive and negative. Gallup’s research shows that teams with regular feedback have 14.9% lower turnover rates. That’s no small feat when the competition for talent is fierce.
Without feedback, you’ll see your best people heading for the door, and trust me, in a small town like Farmington, word gets around fast.
The Danger of Ruinous Empathy
4. Stop Being Too Nice—Ruinous Empathy Is Killing Your Business
We all want to be liked, but if you care too much about hurting feelings and avoid giving tough feedback, congratulations—you’re practicing “Ruinous Empathy,” and it’s destroying your business. Scott calls this out: “Ruinous Empathy is responsible for the vast majority of management mistakes I’ve seen in my career.” So, if you’re ducking the hard conversations, quit it. Now.
5. Avoiding the Hard Truths Will Destroy Your Team
When you’re too scared to tell your team where they’re messing up, you’re sabotaging them. Instead of creating a culture of excellence, you’re cultivating complacency. And when your top performers realize they’re carrying the dead weight, they’ll bolt. Guaranteed.
6. The Radical Candor Solution: Direct and Caring
Radical Candor is the antidote to Ruinous Empathy. It’s about caring enough to challenge your team directly. If you don’t care enough to tell someone they need to step up, you’re doing them—and your business—a disservice.
How to Build a Feedback-First Culture
7. Establish a Regular Feedback Cadence
Don’t make feedback a once-a-year affair. It should happen consistently—weekly, even daily. It keeps everyone aligned and avoids surprise meltdowns in annual reviews.
Pro Tip: Block out time for weekly one-on-ones with your team. Keep it focused on what’s working and what’s not.
8. Encourage Peer-to-Peer Feedback
Feedback shouldn’t just come from the top. Your team should be comfortable giving constructive feedback to each other. That’s how you build accountability.
Action: Set up regular peer feedback sessions—quick, constructive, and no passive-aggression allowed.
9. Train Managers to Master Radical Candor
Your managers need to learn how to balance caring personally with challenging directly. If they can’t, they’re managing with blinders on.
Pro Tip: Host a Radical Candor workshop or better yet, grab a copy here and make it required reading for your team.
Conclusion: Build the Feedback Culture That Saves Your Business
If you’re not giving feedback, you’re not leading. Start those tough conversations today, and while you’re at it, big thanks to Farmington Storage for keeping our baggage neatly tucked away. If they can handle the emotional weight of bad feedback, they can handle your storage needs.
And don’t forget, The Farmington Mercury is your go-to for everything local. From zoning regulations to the 2024 elections, we cover it all. Want to know what’s happening in Farmington High School sports or local job opportunities? We’ve got you.
Stay caffeinated,
Henry “Artie” Whitfield
Tech Strategist, Feedback Ninja, and a guy who drinks way too much coffee before making big decisions.
Stay Informed with The Farmington Mercury
Don’t miss a beat! Stay up to date with all things local by following our Election 2024 coverage here, or better yet, subscribe for exclusive content, interviews, and more.
